Firefighters: Compare Gasoline, Electric and Battery-Powered Fans
Ventry Solutions does not yet make a battery-powered fan. We make only gas-powered and electric Ventry® Ventilation Fans which have proven safe and effective for nearly three decades. All of our fans are exceptional for positive pressure ventilation (PPV) and attack.
Ventry Fans and battery fans are very different tools for very different tasks. Based on our direct experience and study, we believe battery-powered fans are insufficient for PPV when run off a battery (all battery powered fans have two air volumes specified: one if run off battery and one if plugged in).
Battery powered fans do appear to be a good solution for situations requiring them to be carried indoors, for ventilating a small interior area, without introducing any CO, and for short-term use (as are electric fans).
Gas fans remain the best choice for fire fighters who implement coordinated ventilation during which firefighters follow the fresh air in. Gas fans can achieve high (or low) air volume as needed.
Gas PPV fans, as well as our one high-output electric fan, continue to be safe, reliable, high-performance, long-lasting solutions for our customers. They are and will continue to be best for fire departments who use aggressive horizontal or mechanical ventilation during coordinated attack (see training and research by UL Firefighter Safety Research Institute).
James, our CEO, Mechanical Engineer, a firefighter, and instructor with several decades of experience, shared his thoughts on the battery-powered fans. He sees value in them (as stated above), but expressed grave concerns with the battery chemistries and how they may be affected by heat.
Firefighting fans are used in hot environments and are run for long periods of time, during which they may be subject to overheating. Operation may be needed well above the operating temperatures specified for bat-fans. (Before buying, note every battery-powered fan’s operating temperatures.)
As a PPV fan manufacturer and firefighter, James’s other concerns with battery-powered fans include:
- air volume (CFM is much lower than gas, making them safe for very limited ventilation situations)
- run-times and reliability during ventilation
- battery safety
- limited range of use temperatures
- down-time while battery charges (emergency availability)
- battery life
- long-term cost and availability of batteries
- overall value and costs (especially cost versus performance and longevity)
We anticipate these concerns being resolved as the market and technology evolve, and we hope this occurs without injury to firefighters! While the unknowns work themselves out, we continue to make exceptional, out-STAND-ing, tried and true fans which work for nearly any ventilation situation.
More info: 7 Questions Before You Buy Any PPV Fan
Share this post
Latest News & Articles
Incidents Happen After Dark Too
An Emergency Management Department in South Dakota recently purchased a couple Lentry Lighting Systems and has put them to good use at various incidents where lighting was difficult, making the scenes safer for all involved.
Photos compare lighting options for Linemen
Photos by local linemen: They tested safety lighting solutions during overhead pole work and trench work. Photos compare headlights, spotlight, and Lentry® Portable Lighting.
A Ventry Fan assists with burning brush piles
The all-terrain legs, safety propellers, and high CFM offered on all Ventry® Fans make them a great tool to use while burning brush and slash. The piles burn hotter, faster, and cleaner, often making multiple days' work into one.
Stay in touch
We’d love to hear from you and will be happy to answer your questions and assist you with our products. Call (888) 257-8967.
Sign up here for our once-a-month email of GREAT NEWS!